Mailing List flyrotary@lancaironline.net Message #33089
From: Bob White <rlwhite@comcast.net>
Subject: Re: [FlyRotary] First flight - Oil temp
Date: Sun, 6 Aug 2006 20:41:56 -0600
To: Rotary motors in aircraft <flyrotary@lancaironline.net>
Hi Al,

I'm sitting here trying to compile a program that won't, so I might as
well give you my uninformed opinion. :)

I agree with you that (c) would be worth a try.  It's sort of brute
force to get something to work, then try to clean it up later.  I also
wonder if the exit scoop might not work better if the slope went up
more gradually, more like a triangle than a box.  OK, I'll attach a
picture.

Bob W.

On Sun, 6 Aug 2006 18:45:05 -0700
"Al Gietzen" <ALVentures@cox.net> wrote:

Thanks everyone for the congratulatory messages, and for the support that is
always so helpful.  No pics to post yet because my camera battery went dead
after the first three shots, so I’m awaiting for shots from my friend who
took hundreds (OK, only about 150) and will be editing for a while :-).

 

The principal issue of the day was the higher than comfortable oil
temperature; most likely due to insufficient air flow through the cooler.
For anyone who would like to think aerodynamics for awhile and give an
opinion on the simplest and best approach to remedy; read on.

 

The custom cooler for this 265 hp engine is large.  The core here is about 5
¼” wide, 22” long and 3 ¼” thick. It is located in the wing root of the
Velocity, behind the spar, with inlet underneath and exit on the top.  Alan
Shaw, who I believe pioneered this approach, found the location worked very
well.  When I discussed the installation with him years ago, he opined that
a scoop under the wing was probably not necessary because of a pressure
differential between bottom and top surfaces.  Since then, my investigations
of pressure distributions, and similar installations that aren’t working so
well, make me wonder.

 

Photo 1 is a view under the wing showing the OC air intake, wheel well, and
the big armpit scoop for the coolant radiator in the cowl.  The inlet
opening is about 1 1/8” wide and 23” long.  There really isn’t a scoop, just
an opening with an extended airfoil shaped lip which extends about ½” into
the free stream.  The idea was to minimize drag, and assume a more negative
pressure at the exit would produce the necessary flow.  Photo 2 shows a
front view where you see the wheel well and the inlet – very little
extension into the free stream.  Analysis suggests that the turbulent
boundary layer on a smooth surface at the inlet location could be about 5/8
– 3/4” in thick.

 

The air exit fairing is shown in photo 3; and is shaped as it is to maintain
attached flow and cause minimal turbulence going aft.  The effective exit
area is about 1.6 times the inlet area.  The thickness of the core suggests
the need for pretty good pressure differential for adequate flow.

 

Here are some options:

a)  For the first flight the landing gear was never retracted. Since the
open wheel well forward of the inlet would likely cause significant
turbulence; try another flight with the gear retracted to see if that
improves the results.

b)    Place some VGs forward of the inlet to ‘energize’ the boundary layer,
and see if that helps.

 

c)     Extend the ‘lip’ of the inlet to form a proper ram scoop, possible
also with VGs forward to break up the boundary layer, and accept the slight
increase in drag.

 

d)    Do something at the exit ( local ‘expert’ suggests there may be flow
separation before the aft end of the fairing causing high pressure behind
the exit).  Put VGs on the top of the exit fairing and/or reduce exit area.

 

e)    None of the above.

 

I suspect the normal aerodynamic pressure differential between the inlet and
outlet points is minimal; especially in level flight where it could be near
zero.  Option c) seems the most sure-fire to me.

Thanks for input.

 

Al

 




--
http://www.bob-white.com
N93BD - Rotary Powered BD-4 (first engine start 1/7/06)
Custom Cables for your rotary installation -
http://www.roblinphoto.com/shop/
Subscribe (FEED) Subscribe (DIGEST) Subscribe (INDEX) Unsubscribe Mail to Listmaster