|
In a message dated 12/24/2005 8:17:22 P.M. Central Standard Time,
glcasey@adelphia.net writes:
Lots of
good comments on this issue, but I feel the need to clarify a few
issues. First, there seems to be a consensus that EI provides a
"hotter and longer" spark. sometimes true, but the most common
EI product is a capacitive discharge (CD) system. The
inductive (Kettering) system stores energy by using the inductance
of the ignition coil and the spark occurs when the current in the
primary is interrupted. These system, which include magnetos,
are characterized by having a relatively slow voltage rise time, but
a fairly long spark duration at a low current level. A CD
system stores energy at high voltage in a capacitor and the spark
occurs when this is discharged into the coil. Since the coil
isn't required to store the total spark energy it can be smaller and
of lower inductance. The result is a very fast rise time, high
spark current and a very short duration. A short-duration
spark works fine as long as there is a combustible mixture in the
spark gap at the moment of the spark. CD systems work very
well in engines that tend to foul plugs, which is why their initial
popularity was in 2-stroke engines, but they typically don't work
very well in engines that operate with "poor" mixture preparation,
such as automotive engines running a lot of EGR. I see no
problem using CD technology in aircraft engines as we don't
typically operate at very light loads with EGR, except at
idle. The CD system is far more electronically complex than an
inductive system, which only requires an electronic switch to
activate the coil. The automotive guys have spent billions
researching ignition systems with the result that all automotive
engines worldwide still use the original Kettering inductive
system. The CD coils weigh less, but the electronics weigh
more. I agree with Walter that the higher spark current will
result in a faster initial burn, creating an effective timing
advance compared to a conventional
system.
Gary,
May be true for some. But LSE claims:
<<<<<
The PLASMA III is Light Speed Engineering's high
performance continuous spark capacitor discharge ignition system. The
Plasma III has a dual output stage which allows the spark to oscillate back and
forth for a minimum of 20 degrees crankshaft rotation. This long duration
spark allows further leaning without lean misfiring for added fuel efficiency it
also noticeably increases horsepower output and engine
smoothness. >>>>>>
See:
I don't have the test equipment to check this - just the resulting
performance.
Scott Krueger
AKA Grayhawk Lancair N92EX IO320 SB 89/96 Aurora, IL (KARR)
Merry
Christmas to all!
|
|