Mailing List lml@lancaironline.net Message #45643
From: Paul Lipps <elippse@sbcglobal.net>
Sender: <marv@lancaironline.net>
Subject: PRISM
Date: Mon, 07 Jan 2008 00:29:54 -0500
To: <lml@lancaironline.net>
Prism! Prism! Prism! 'Sorta reminds me of a friend who won't buy a new computer because he's so sure that as soon as he buys one, someone else will come along with a computer for sale that's faster, has more memory, and costs less. PLASMA uses MAP and rpm to determine timing, and Klaus has taken a very conservative approach, even 'tho he's a liberal, to avoid any timing that could result in detonation - pre-ignition. This timing curve is a result of his many hours of experimentation, and is proprietary, so he's obviously not going to give it out! This timing may not be the absolute best obtained by measuring individual cylinder pressures and adjusting individual cylinder ignition timing to get right up next to this very-best-of-all-worlds timing where LPP, location of peak pressure, is at 14 deg ATDC, but consider how much more complex and costly that approach must be; more sensors to go bad, more wiring to break. Let's see. If you lose one sensor, and the other 3 or 5 are at peak, and this one is at something less than peak, will the engine still run smoothly? Will having every cylinder pressure sensor working before takeoff be a requirement, and how will it be tested on run-up? The PLASMA is a simple but very good analog EI, and a lot of it is due to its NOT being digital! Go on the VANS forum, and read all of the postings about a very popular ignition system that's up to V25 or V26 of its software. Would you like to keep sending in your ignition system for updating every time a new software bug is discovered? Has your home computer ever gone off to Never-Never Land?
    I've designed digital with DCTL, RTL, TTL, ECL, and CMOS, and I've designed analog circuits from DC to X-band, and I know the pluses and minuses of each. I worked on four different computers that were used for the guidance of the Atlas ICBM, Titan range safety, guidance of the Atlas used for re-entry vehicle testing,  and guidance of the Atlas Space Booster - the Burroughs J3, IBM 7088 and 7090, and Harris /4. I've always pointed out to my digital-only compatriots that digital is just analog driven to saturation and cut-off! And when they get into the high speed stuff, they'd better know about analog stuff like transmission lines and reflections and capacitive loading and wire inductance.
    So, what is the latest release date of PRISM?
Subscribe (FEED) Subscribe (DIGEST) Subscribe (INDEX) Unsubscribe Mail to Listmaster