In a message dated 10/5/2006 9:26:12 P.M. Central Daylight Time,
leighton@teleport.com writes:
The recent discussions about proper torque on such things as
engine mount bolts reminds me that over the years I have heard from several
normally reliable sources that using a torque wrench on locking nuts (either
plastic or all metal) is not only a waste of time but possibly even a bad
idea. The logic is that because of the built in interference of the nut
either a lower than desired reading will be read or upon approaching the
desired torque the nut will "slip" and result in higher than desired
torque. It's been pointed out that truly torque-critical items, like
connecting rod bolts and case half connecting bolts never use locking
nuts. In other words, if the torque is really important don't use lock
nuts. I am curious what others on the list might have to say about
this. I am not an engineer, nor do I play one on TV, but I've been using
nuts and bolts since way back in the Erector Set days and have absorbed "do"
and "don't do" advice from people whose expertise I respect, including the
above observations on torquing fasteners. I probably won't change what's
worked well for me over the decades but perhaps someone has some compelling
argument to the contrary, or perhaps confirm what I've heard. The floor
is open.
Leighton,
Proper torque........Hmmmm...
Since I am a simple minded person, all I know is that there are many
bolt-type fasteners that must be tight enough. Ignoring my heritage, where
"Gut und Tite" was the rule (just short of stripping the threads), there has to
be a method/standard for consistently tightening a bolt to properly perform its
design function in the place it is being used. Usually there is
a reference based on the bolt size, quality and thread spacing.
This reference sometimes contains notes about lubricated threads and
the effect on the torque.
Aircraft reference tables don't mention using fiber locking nuts but it is
hard to find a fastener in an aircraft that does not use them - including
locking nut plates. Also, there is no special reference to high temp steel
locking nuts. I use the AN bolt torque tables unless the use
is only for shear or some other special application. For engine
bolts/nuts, I reference the appropriate overhaul manual.
I rationalize my use by noting that fiber/steel locking nuts do
not add that much resistance - maybe a few percentage points above that of a
non-locking nut. Good enough for me since I do not regularly re-calibrate
my torque wrenches. I prefer that the bolts be slightly off torque rather than
grossly off torque since my arm hasn't been calibrated in years either.
Scott Krueger
AKA Grayhawk
LNC2 N92EX IO 320 SB 89/96
On
Vacation