Mailing List flyrotary@lancaironline.net Message #65636
From: eanderson@carolina.rr.com <flyrotary@lancaironline.net>
Subject: Re: [FlyRotary] Re: Eds engine removal at the Tracy Crook Repair Facility
Date: Sun, 03 May 2020 16:54:36 +0000
To: Rotary motors in aircraft <flyrotary@lancaironline.net>
You are absolutely correct, Charlie.  I did put a switch guard on that switch after that engine-out glide/landing.

I guess your incident  goes to show, incidents can happens even with Lycoming powered projects.

Ed

------ Original Message ------
To: "Rotary motors in aircraft" <flyrotary@lancaironline.net>
Sent: 5/2/2020 2:17:44 PM
Subject: [FlyRotary] Re: Eds engine removal at the Tracy Crook Repair Facility

On 5/2/2020 12:13 PM, eanderson@carolina.rr.com wrote:
Prelude to this engine removal.  I had recently (10 hours previous) rebuilt my rotary engine after it had swallowed an apex seal.  I flew down to visit Tracy Crook at Shady Bend and several other rotary lovers were there also.  After taking the cowl off, I was showing how the Mustang 65MM Throttle body on my engine was rigged to fully open.  Afterwards as it was getting dark, we adjourned to Tracy's house to an excellent  rotary dinner prepared by Laura and spend the night.  

The next morning arrived bright and a bit cool, just a great day for flying a rotary.  So Tracy, Finn and I decided to fire up the girls and go for a flight.  The first thing that happend to me was when I fired up the engine, it immediately rev to high rpm - yeah, the dummy had forgotten to close the throttle after the demo of the preceeding evening and we all know how quickly the rotary can rev.  Well, my lighten quick reflex chopped throttle before it got past 5000 rpm, so all is good.

We three then decided to proceed with the take off and flight.  Now Tracy and Finn decided that rather than taxi to the far end of the runway, that given the very slight breeze, they both elected to take off down wind.  Well, my bird was a bit heavier and I just never, never liked taking off downwind.  So as Tracy and Finn soared overhead, I was taxing to the far end of the runway.  While taxing I noticed my oil pressure was hovering around 20-25 psi.  Humm, I thought a bit on the low side (normally at idle the pressure was around 60 psi), but told myself the engine was still cold and the oil a bit sluggist.  But, even when I reved the engine the oil pressure stayed below 30 psi.  

Well, I couldn't stand it.  I aborted the decision to launch and slowly taxied back down to Tracy's hangar.  On  Tracys returned we discuss possible causes including faulty sensor/gauge, impeded oil flow, and others.  Well, everything seem to check out OK.  But, I just couldn't leave it at that.  That little uneasy feeling just wouldn't go away.

So decided to take the engine off.  To do that because of my plugs-up engine orientation, i have to take off the sidemount oil pan.  well as I removed the last oil pan bolt and pulled the oil pan away from the engine I heard a metalic clank inside the oil pan.  Further examination revealed a chunk of metal in the shape of a cresent moon - Ah ha! the light bulb comes on that looks like a woodruff key!

It turns out that during my reassembly after the rebuild that when I pushed the spocked oil pump Gear on its shaft, I apparently pushed the woodruff key out of its slot and into the oil pan.  Now I did put plenty of torque on the tightening nut and apparaently that is what I had been flying with for the last 10 hours.  However, the rapid rpm increase on that cold morning with the heavy oil apparently broke the torque hold of the nut and the sprocket was slowly slipping on the shaft producing some oil pressure but not what was needed and would have probably stopped producing any pressure with a little it more turning and wearing on the shaft.

Who knows how long the nut torque would have held had I not accidently reveved up the engine on that old morning or where it may have failed.  Made me shudder thinking about my flights over the Georgia Okefenokee  500,000 acre swamp.  As I write this I happened to look on my office wall where there is an "Award" from Real World Solutions (Tracy and Laural Crook).  

This award is titled "Lightening Strikes Six times (or More) Award presented to Ed Anderson for Discovering the most unlikely failure modes in rotary powered aicraft, including (but not Limited to):
Hung flop tube-fuel Starvation, Spontaneous fuel combusion (open gas tank refuling on cold dry morning), Oil pump key drop out, Ballast coil resistor failure in ignition module, Tire shredding wheel pant Hardware, busted brakeline oil fire (destorying tire and wheel pant), etc,.  But, never was any of these problems the fault of the engine itself.

So be careful folks, your guardian angle might not be as proficient as mine was :-)
That award must have been prior to the 'alternator switch off battery dead 12 mile glide' incident; pretty sure that would have made the award list, too. ;-)

And from the 'you're not alone' department:

In our Lyc powered RV6, one ignition switch controls a Lightspeed electronic ignition, and I recently rewired the plane so it's fed from the battery bus. You know, so that in case of smoke in the cockpit, I can make the whole a/c 'cold' without killing the ignition.
Tupper's been wanting to go flying for a couple of weeks; she basically can't leave the house until the Covid issue is solved (compromised immune system). Yesterday, I pulled all the orifice plugs, checked the oil, fuel, controls, etc. We got in, and when I flipped the master on....nothing; total darkness. I looked at the ignition switches, and both were on. Duh....  I think I'll be moving the Lighspeed to the Endurance bus (and being a little more careful when doing my post-flight...).

Charlie

Virus-free. www.avast.com
Image
zcgiyphr.png
Subscribe (FEED) Subscribe (DIGEST) Subscribe (INDEX) Unsubscribe Mail to Listmaster